Badenoch says using amputee athletes to justify cutting disability benefits was ‘message of hope’
Good morning. At PMQs yesterday Andy Burnham said that Kemi Badenoch should withdraw the “double amputees run marathons” comment that she used to justify the Tory plan to cut sickness and disability benefits by £14bn. It was “crass and insensitive”, he said.
This morning Badenoch defended what she was saying claimed that, in fact, she was delivering a “message of hope”.
In an interview on the Today programme, asked if she accepted that her remark was insensitive, Badenoch said she didn’t. She went on:
I will speak the truth and I will say what I believe is common sense. And what I know is that, if people can work, then we should encourage them to work.
And what I’m saying is actually a message of hope, that if people even with significant, problems can work, then those who have ADHD and mild anxiety should go to work.
When the presenter, Nick Robinson, put it to her that it was unreasonable to use an exceptional case as a guide to what most disabled people should be doing, Badenoch did not agree. “We do use extreme examples to illustrate things,” she said.
Robinson tried again, saying she was taking “one extreme case [to] imply that anybody on disability benefits should just get on with it”. Badenoch accused him of “faux outrage” and “tone policing”. She added:
People are free to disagree, but they know where I’m coming from.
I will post more from the interview shortly.
Today the news will be dominated by two summits. This afternoon Burnham is in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. We have coverage of this on our Europe live blog.
And in China, Vladimir Putin, who invaded Ukraine, Xi Jinping, his leading ally, and Donald Trump, who is seen by many as a closet Putin ally, are meeting now. You can read about that here.
We will have comments open in about an hour. That is because I will be doing a Q&A this afternoon, probably from about 3pm, and I will try to answer as many questions as possible. Do post them below the line.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Louise Haigh, the first secretary of state and Cabinet Office minister, takes questions in the Commons.
10am: The Conservative party announces the results of the first round of voting in the election of its candidate for London mayor for 2028. James Cleverly, the former home secretary and former foreign secretary, is expected to get more than 50% of the vote, meaning a second round of voting should not be necessary.
11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
Noon: Heather Hallett, the Covid inquiry chair, publishes her report on the test, trace and isolate system.
Around 12.15pm (UK time): Andy Burnham arrives in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. He is expected to speak to the media later in the afternoon after the plenary has finished.
1pm: Chris Bryant, the Northern Ireland secretary, attends a meeting of the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference in Dublin.
Key events
Tories choose James Cleverly as their candidate for London mayor in 2028
James Cleverly has been selected as the Conservative party’s candidate for the next London mayoral election.
The former foreign secretary and former home secretary won 86% of the votes in the ballot, beating Westminster councillor Festus Akinbusoye and former parliamentary candidate Sara Gezdari. A fourth candidate, communications professional Alex Challoner, was eliminated before the shortlist was drawn up for the ballot.
The next election for London mayor will take place in 2028.
Cleverly said he was “all in” for the race and would not be seeking reselection as an MP. He represents Braintree in Essex.
After the result was announced, Cleverly said the current mayor, Labour’s Sadiq Khan, was letting London down. He said:
People are leaving London, or not choosing to come here in the first place, businesses, job creators, families leaving London, and by the time of the election in 2028, Khan will have been mayor for 12 years, and those two things are related.
The problems London faces are the symptoms. Khan is the cause.
When I ask Londoners, do you feel safe walking home at night? The answer is no.
It’s shameful, it’s a failure, and it’s not just crime.
We have had the worst period of housebuilding since the second world war and only the highest-earning Londoners can afford the cheapest houses in London.
Congratulating Cleverly, Kemi Badenoch said London was in decline and Labour was to blame.
Any questions for Andrew Sparrow?
This afternoon I will be answering questions from readers. Please post your questions below the line (comments are open today), and I will be answering from about 3pm until 5pm, or a bit later.
This is the latest in a regular Conversations series where Guardian journalists answer questions from readers. I last did one in April.
Please feel free to ask about anything related to British politics. I will try to answer as many as I can, but in particular I will focus on a) the ones that seem most interesting and b) the ones where I think I might have something sensible to say.
Tulip Siddiq says she is considering legal action against former Bangladesh leader
The former minister Tulip Siddiq has said she is considering taking legal action against the former interim leader of Bangladesh over corruption allegations made by his administration led her to resign from the UK government last year, Alexandra Topping reports.
In her Today programme interview, Kemi Badenoch said that she was “worried” by the idea of the government intervening to get the Russell Brand prison message video removed from YouTube. (See 10.04am.) She said that, while Brand had been convicted, his wife (who posted the video) was a separate person.
Badenoch said:
My personal opinion is that Russell Brand has been convicted. He is guilty under the law. The rule of law applies to everyone in this country.
His wife is a separate person. She can make the protestations that she likes. I’m very concerned if people in prison are able to use other conduits to be able to send messages. I think that that is unorthodox.
But YouTube is a private platform. I think that immediately demanding the private platforms take things down without looking at exactly whether a law has been broken is not where I would start from.
If we want to make legislation for that, then we can look at that. But I’m quite worried about government intervening.
During his interview round this morning, Matthew Pennycook said the Ministry of Justice is in “dialogue” with Google as it tries to get the tech firm to take down the Russell Brand video. (See 10.04pm.)
A spokesperson for the Ministry of Justice said:
It is only right that the government asks for content that is distressing for victims to be taken down and we strongly believe YouTube should remove this content.
Removal ultimately depends on the platform’s own terms.
Meta disabled Brand’s Instagram and Facebook accounts after his conviction, the Press Association reports.
A Google spokesperson said:
We’re aware of the new content and our teams are investigating. We suspended Russell Brand’s channel from the YouTube Partner Programme in September 2023. The channel has not been able to monetise on YouTube since then.
Minister admits government cannot force Google to remove Russell Brand prison video from YouTube
The government has no power to make Google take down a YouTube video with a message from Russell Brand from prison claiming he is innocent of his crimes, a minister has admitted.
As Nadeem Badshah reports, the government has asked Google to take down the video.
Google has reportedly denied the request because it determined its rules had not been broken, the Press Association reports.
Asked about this in an interview on BBC Breakfast this morning, Matthew Pennycook, the housing minister, said:
We don’t have any power to mandate a removal of content. That is up to Google. It’s based on their terms and conditions.
But as I’ve been very clear, we’ve made a request in this instance because we feel very strongly that victims shouldn’t have to see this content.
We hope they do so because they have taken action on their platform before. They banned, for example in 2023, Russell Brand for making money off the platform because his off-platform behaviour was seen to cause harm.
BAE to slash 1,000 jobs across head office and air business to streamline orders
BAE Systems has announced plans to cut more than 1,000 jobs from its workforce, triggering calls for ministers to place extra orders with Britain’s biggest defence contractor, Lauren Almeida and Jasper Jolly report.
Badenoch says it’s ‘disturbing’ that Xi, Trump and Putin look like they’re ‘trying to carve up world between them’

Alexandra Topping
Alexandra Topping is a Guardian political correspondent.
Kemi Badenoch was in a straight-talking mode on the media round this morning, calling the historic meeting between Trump, Xi and Putin “disturbing”, saying it looked like they were trying to “carve” up the world” between them.
Speaking on the Today programme, the leader of the opposition said the meeting was “absolutely not reassuring”.
She said:
There are three world leaders who look like they’re trying to carve up the world between them, a tri-polar world where Xi gets Asia, America gets the western hemisphere and Russia gets Europe, and that is very concerning, especially seeing Donald Trump call President Putin his friend.
Russia is not America’s friend, it certainly hasn’t been during my lifetime. But also at a time when we’re all worried about where the Ukraine war is going, the message that is sending to President Zelensky and of course the other summit that is taking place … is very concerning indeed.
And what I want to know is where we fit in in all of this. I don’t want to be in a polarised world run by Russia. I’ll do everything I can to make sure that doesn’t happen.
Badenoch went further than the prime minister, who was asked about the meeting by Ed Davey at prime minister’s questions yesterday. The Liberal Democrat leader said “the security implications of Trump, Putin and Xi cosying up” should highlight the need for a fresh deal with the European Union.
Burnham replied that he would be in Berlin for a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing to support Ukraine in China, but stopped short of expressing concern about the meeting of the three world leaders.
He said:
The thing that we need to do is continue to stand squarely by Ukraine and that is what this government will do.
And on this issue, I do pay tribute to all sides of the house because that is what we’ve managed to do in the years since the conflict began and that is the right thing to do … Let that clear message go out as that meeting takes place in [China] – this country is squarely with Ukraine.
Badenoch says using amputee athletes to justify cutting disability benefits was ‘message of hope’
Good morning. At PMQs yesterday Andy Burnham said that Kemi Badenoch should withdraw the “double amputees run marathons” comment that she used to justify the Tory plan to cut sickness and disability benefits by £14bn. It was “crass and insensitive”, he said.
This morning Badenoch defended what she was saying claimed that, in fact, she was delivering a “message of hope”.
In an interview on the Today programme, asked if she accepted that her remark was insensitive, Badenoch said she didn’t. She went on:
I will speak the truth and I will say what I believe is common sense. And what I know is that, if people can work, then we should encourage them to work.
And what I’m saying is actually a message of hope, that if people even with significant, problems can work, then those who have ADHD and mild anxiety should go to work.
When the presenter, Nick Robinson, put it to her that it was unreasonable to use an exceptional case as a guide to what most disabled people should be doing, Badenoch did not agree. “We do use extreme examples to illustrate things,” she said.
Robinson tried again, saying she was taking “one extreme case [to] imply that anybody on disability benefits should just get on with it”. Badenoch accused him of “faux outrage” and “tone policing”. She added:
People are free to disagree, but they know where I’m coming from.
I will post more from the interview shortly.
Today the news will be dominated by two summits. This afternoon Burnham is in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. We have coverage of this on our Europe live blog.
And in China, Vladimir Putin, who invaded Ukraine, Xi Jinping, his leading ally, and Donald Trump, who is seen by many as a closet Putin ally, are meeting now. You can read about that here.
We will have comments open in about an hour. That is because I will be doing a Q&A this afternoon, probably from about 3pm, and I will try to answer as many questions as possible. Do post them below the line.
Here is the agenda for the day.
9.30am: Louise Haigh, the first secretary of state and Cabinet Office minister, takes questions in the Commons.
10am: The Conservative party announces the results of the first round of voting in the election of its candidate for London mayor for 2028. James Cleverly, the former home secretary and former foreign secretary, is expected to get more than 50% of the vote, meaning a second round of voting should not be necessary.
11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.
Noon: Heather Hallett, the Covid inquiry chair, publishes her report on the test, trace and isolate system.
Around 12.15pm (UK time): Andy Burnham arrives in Berlin for a meeting of the pro-Ukraine coalition of the willing. He is expected to speak to the media later in the afternoon after the plenary has finished.
1pm: Chris Bryant, the Northern Ireland secretary, attends a meeting of the British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference in Dublin.
Source: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/live/2026/nov/19/kemi-badenoch-andy-burnham-uk-politics-latest-news-updates